Wholefood versus Refined Food

The human organism itself is able to process food until it is refined enough to be absorbed into the circulation of blood and lymph. For this purpose both physical and chemical methods are used to break down the ingested food into basic nutrients that can be assimilated by our body. Regular consumption of wholefood strengthens our digestive ‘muscles’ – that is our forces which are active in the breaking-down activities, while regular consumption of refined food progressively weakens our digestive forces.

Activities of Refining in the Digestive Tract

After we have eaten, food is subjected to various breaking-down activities and processes. [1] These processes start in the mouth by chewing – that is, by physical breakdown – which enables transformation of food from whatever shape and texture it had before into a soft consistency. After this the food is swallowed and proceeds into the stomach.

Food is also subjected to multiple chemical breaking-down processes. These are facilitated through the excretion of the digestive juices. On average we excrete seven litres  of digestive juices per day:

In these digestive juices three different types of enzymes are present:

Carbohydrates are subjected to three stages of chemical breakdown:

The outcomes of these processes are glucose and other simple sugars.

Proteins are subjected to two stages of chemical breakdown:

The outcomes of these processes are amino acids.

Fats are subjected to one stage of chemical breakdown:

The outcomes of this process are fatty acids and glycerol.

The final outcome of all these activities is chyme. Besides simple sugars, amino acids, fatty acids and glycerol, it contains water, dissolved minerals, and any undigested substances, of which the majority is plant fibre.

In the small intestine, as the chyme moves along, the individual nutrients (simple sugars, amino acids, fatty acids, etc.) are selected and absorbed into the body. The rest (so-called waste material) moves into the large intestine and is finally eliminated as a stool.

Industrial versus Bodily Food Refining

Industrial refining is mainly used in the processing of grains, sugar, oils and salt. With a few exceptions this involves the physical breakdown of food before refining can start. Refining is the process of 'purification' where a desired ingredient is separated from so-called residues and by-products. While in the case of petroleum these impurities will clog an engine if it is not refined beforehand, the situation with food is quite different.

In the case of carbohydrate foods the refining process removes the following 'impurities':

Awareness of the importance of dietary fibre, minerals and vitamins is common knowledge in modern societies. In the case of fibre it is well documented that a lack of these 'residues' causes the very opposite: it causes constipation, the equivalent to the clogging of an engine.

There is another important difference. Take for example the production of pure fructose, which can be nowadays bought as a 'natural' substitute for ordinary sugar. Fructose is in chemical terms monosaccharide, consisting of one single molecule of sugar. When it is produced in a factory, industrial refining processes take place until pure fructose crystals are separated from the rest of the fruit.

When we ourselves eat fruit our organism breaks it down. At the end pure fructose is extracted and absorbed into the body. What is not absorbed, what has remained rough and coarse, is eliminated. We can therefore characterize this as a process of inner refining performed by our own organism.

The main difference between industrial refining and our own refining of food is that in the first case the work is done for us beforehand by means of technology, and in the second case we do the work ourselves. While sometimes it is beneficial if the work is done for us, in this case the outcome is quite the contrary. For we need to be aware that we become strong if we exercise our digestive 'muscles' by doing all the breaking-down which is typical for our digestive organs. This is so because "the organism is a relationship of activities. The essence of the organism lies in action, not in substance. The organization is not relationship of substance; it is an activity." [2] And we become progressively weaker if we do not use our digestive 'muscles' as much as we are capable of.

The Loss of Essential Nutrients and Its Consequences

We will look now on a particular aspect of the refining of grains [3] – at the loss of vital ingredients which are removed in the process of extraction – and what kind of problems occur as the consequence of regular consumption of such nutritionally inferior cereal products. The refining process belongs to those food processing methods which aim to extract a particular substance out of the whole(food). For that reason we will start with the picture of gradual progression of the processes of extraction of specific ingredients from the grain kernel which are simultaneously also processes of refinement. [4]

The most common examples of refined grain products are white wheat flour and white rice. Both belong to the second stage of extraction/refining where we lose both the bran and the germ. For that reason we need to ask: What kind of substances are lost in this case? What is their essential nature?

First we will look at bran. In bran we find the highest concentration of dietary fibre – that is, carbohydrates which have metamorphosed into cellulose and other indigestible substances. In COSMIC ORIGIN OF LIVING SUBSTANCES and in THE TRUE NATURE OF NUTRITIVE SUBSTANCES are described the formative characters of carbon and carbohydrates. We can see this attribute even more clearly in the case of indigestible carbohydrates, such as cellulose, etc., because plants built their own bodies with their help. These fibrous substances also form the outer layer of the grain, thus defining the shape of the grain. Their function is similar to when we draw with pencil – made from another form of carbon, graphite – the shape of the grain. For that reason we can characterise the forces active in the grain's skin as condensed formative forces, the forces which give shape and form. These forces are mediated by the means of fibrous carbohydrates. Any loss of these substances means also the loss of those forces which "help to give our human form its proper shape." [5]

On the other side we have the germ, which is like a small seed inside the grain, out of which the process of sprouting starts – that is, the beginning of a new plant. Spiritual forces behind the germ are forces of regeneration and preservation of life. These forces are, of course, in all living substances, but in the germ they are most concentrated. With the removal of germ, we remove a great amount of these forces. Although in regard to physical weight wheat germ presents only 3% of a grain, there is no sprouting possible if the germ is removed or if it is only damaged. This demonstrates the great significance of forces working through the germ, and explains why regular consumption of refined food where germs are removed promotes weakening of our own etheric body, the source of our inner forces of regeneration and renewal of the physical body.

From the above description it is evident that the regular consumption of refined foods, such as white bread, white rice, white pasta, cakes and biscuits made from white flour, and similar refined products, will sooner or later cause various health problems. There exists more than plenty of literature about the negative effects of regular diet based on such refined foods. Today we can also understand the reasons for such effects, if we only look at the list of those minerals and vitamins that are present in the bran and germ, and then investigate their multiple tasks in our organism. We will illustrate this with one example, with iron.

"Iron is an essential mineral nutrient. It is a component of haemoglobin and myoglobin molecules. The haemoglobin in red blood cells transport oxygen from the lungs to body cells and return waste carbon dioxide from the cells to the lungs. The myoglobin in red muscle tissues transports oxygen into the tissues for energy storage. Iron is also a component of certain metabolic enzymes." [6] Iron deficiency leads to the following main symptoms: anaemia, constipation, tiredness, apathy, and reduced brain function. [7]

The loss of iron due to refining, of course, varies due to several factors: the type of grain, the original amount in the grain, the method and degree of refining. For example, in the book Super Breakfast Cereals it is quoted that we have in white flour 42 percent less iron than in the whole wheat kernel. [8] From the next example it is evident that such loss has a significant impact on the level of haemoglobin in the blood: "During the Second World War, the refinement of grain was largely prohibited in order to insure the self-sufficiency of Switzerland. One of the consequences was the clear increase in haemoglobin – the red blood particles – among 700 people tested during their conversion to a diet high in dark bread and vegetables. The average increase was 27% among children and 19% among adults." [9] This was the effect of a few years long diet based on whole grains. [10] Now you can imagine the effect of decades long daily consumption of predominantly or exclusively refined cereal foods. And to this we need to add the transmission of negative effects from one generation to the next. [11]

One may wonder why people do not take into account all available evidence. One reason is the relatively small amounts of minerals and vitamins in comparison with the overall amount of food we consume. But there is a great difference if these small losses are repeated on a daily basis – because the grains are still the daily 'bread' of majority of humanity – or if similar losses occur with any other food we eat regularly. People somehow underestimate the fact that it is not just the question of physical amounts, but the functions of these substances in the human organism.

Another reason is historical. The technologies which made possible refining of grains and sugar on the great scale are the result of industrial revolution. For example, "in England is the year 1800 counted as approximate baseline, as it were, for the dating of general white flour consumption." [12] This means that English are already more than two centuries predominantly consuming white bread. But the understanding of the essential functions of minerals in the human organism is relatively new. The first time the inorganic nutrients were mentioned was at the end of 19th century. However, only in the last few decades of the 20th century did we have a real expansion of research about minerals in our food. Thus we have in some cases about hundred years delay between the implementation of modern refining methods and the basic understanding of all negative health consequences of regular consumption of refined foods.

With the expansion of scientific discoveries about the nutritional importance of minerals and trace elements many people in affluent societies – especially in the United Kingdom and the United States – have adopted the practice of taking mineral supplements on a daily basis to provide themselves with these essential nutrients. Although in this case people have a proper awareness of the importance of extremely small amounts of various minerals in our food – for example, an official ‘recommended dietary allowance’ for iron is only 8 milligrams [13] – all those people who are taking supplements are missing one crucial fact which is presented in this nutritional principle: It is not only important that we obtain specific nutrients in our food, but also how we obtain them. As we have seen, our body can and must extract by itself the basic nutrients from the food we eat.

And how do companies who produce mineral supplements obtain iron, or any other mineral? There are two methods available to them: either they obtain them from inorganic sources, or they extract them from organic materials. In the first case we eat ‘stones’ instead of minerals which have been integrated into living tissue of plants or animals. In the second case we again allow that extraction of these substances is done by industrial means, as is the case with all refined foods. [14]

Thus we can conclude that the main reason contributing to malnourishment with iron – or any other mineral or trace element – is the lack of holistic understanding of nutrition. If people look at the questions of food from a materialistic perspective only – which is quite common even among those who are interested in an holistic approach to nutrition – then they will not see any difference between minerals and vitamins in the food from those which are added to food later [15] or those consumed in the form of food supplements. [16] But immediately one takes into account also the realm of forces and activities of human organism, then things are not so simple any more. As an illustration we will look again at iron – but this time, from a holistic perspective, taking into account also the spiritual forces which are active through the substance of iron.

"Iron mediates between the forces of life and consciousness. It permeates our entire organism. It appears in its most concentrated and mineralized form in the blood. It is always combined with protein. This iron-protein structure appears in various forms, mediating between the unconscious life processes and the consciousness-awakening processes. It mediates between sleeping and waking. Its true home is thus in the rhythmic organism. It joins forces with the circulatory system. There, in our blood, it first exercises its healing function. The red blood cells swim in the blood. By means of iron, they receive the necessary weight and earthly heaviness. This is the physiological basis for the ensoulment of our bodies. Iron is an important regulator of the activity of blood circulation – that is, of the interplay between the etheric and astral organisms. Physical-chemical processes play into our blood, and they are necessary in order for our Ego to participate in the physical world. This points to iron – an inorganic, mineral, even crystalline element – in the erythrocytes." [17]

In 'HOT' vs 'COLD' ILLNESSES we can see the important role of the rhythmic system as balancing mediator between the nerve-sense system and the metabolic-limb system. This role is carried out by means of breathing and blood circulation. In both, iron plays a crucial role. But there is more to it. "If we look at the blood, we look at the something which – in man, because of his human constitution – tends always towards illness. Blood is simply ill by its very nature. The blood process is such that nature herself must constantly bring healing – nature, by means of a mineral, iron, must constantly heal the blood." [18] Beside this we need to get iron on the regular basis, because "out of a total of roughly 25 trillion erythrocytes, some 200 billion perish every day and must be produced anew. Iron is crystallized in every one of these blood cells." [19]

So, looking just at one mineral, iron, from a holistic perspective we see the remarkable significance of minerals and trace minerals present in our food – in greater or lesser degree depending of the methods of food production. However, we must not forget that each person needs to be capable to perform all activities in the body which are related to iron metabolism. For this end we need to have such capacities that enable our organism to deal with iron in such a way that it serves the needs of our individuality.

Thus we can conclude that "without iron, man would, perhaps, attain to life, but he would remain at the level of the plants. Iron makes it possible for him to incorporate his soul-spiritual aspects into his life-body. By means of iron, man's Ego incarnates in the world: it becomes a participant in earthly events." [20]

In NUTRITION & SELF-CONSCIOUSNESS is explained the great role of minerals for proper functioning of our Ego organization. In this context we can understand why our 'I' needs iron to properly incarnate in the physical organism, and why the lack of iron causes people to become anaemic. [21] When people are anaemic, they cannot participate in earthly events to the same extent as would be the case without this obstacle. And this is just one possible negative consequence of regular consumption of refined foods. There are many more, as many as there are minerals in the food we eat.

For complementary perspectives see:

GOOD VERSUS BAD SWEETENERS

LIVING PROCESS OF INNER 'COMBUSTION'

DIETARY CONCLUSIONS & PRACTICAL INSTRUCTIONS

If we compare the effects of eating Wholefood (i.e., whole grains, wholemeal products, whole sugar and other natural sweeteners, etc) with those of eating Refined Food (i.e., refined grains and cereal products, refined sugar, etc.) we see two main differences:

Even if somehow it might be possible to supplement what has been lost by obtaining dietary fibre and essential nutrients from other food sources, the best way is to get them in the original packages (e.g. wholegrain, etc.) for we need them in such combinations and proportions as they exist in their natural forms. However there is no way of making up for the loss of the breaking-down activities due to eating predominantly Refined Food such as white bread, white rice, white pasta, white sugar, etc. A regular diet based on Refined Food will inevitably weaken one's digestive forces – that is, those forces which are active in the breaking-down processes until food is sufficiently refined to be ready for absorption into the blood and lymph circulation.

For that reason eating Wholefood has great advantages. Obviously our digestive system is made for eating Wholefood, but if it has been weakened by years of a diet based on Refined Food, then it is advisable to do the following:

The time-frame and speed of such recovery can considerable vary from person to person. And remember, eating refined cereal products with the addition of bran is not the same as eating whole grains. It is better than eating solely refined cereal products, but with this combination you still do not employ your forces of inner refining in the same measure as is the case with consumption of whole grains.

There is another question which needs to be raised: Is Organic Refined Food a better choice than non-organic refined food? There are some benefits in regard to pesticide residues, etc., but the truth is that in regard to the above mentioned two main disadvantages of eating Refined Food there is no great difference. We are losing essential nutrients and the activity of 'inner refining' in both cases – if we eat non-organic or organic Refined Food! Indeed one can only wonder why one would make such an effort to increase the quality of living soil and consequently the quality of crops, and then, in the case of Organic Refined Foods, all these advantages are literally thrown away through costly and energy-wasteful refining.

For more detailed investigation of this topic see report Is Refined Food Really Organic?

WARNING: You always have to put the above practical dietary instructions inside the framework of GENERAL NUTRITIONAL GUIDELINES with the aim to know their limits when looking for a solution of a specific nutritional problem. You also need to be familiar with THE ROLE OF NUTRITIONAL GUIDELINES with the aim to avoid any one-sided conclusions.

NOTES

  1. Sources: A. Waugh, A. Grant, Ross and Wilson: Anatomy and Physiology in Health and Illness, Elsevier Limited, 2004; A.J. Cichoke, Enzymes – The Sparks of Life, Alive Books, 2002; www.wikipedia
  2. Rudolf Steiner, source unknown
  3. The problems related to refined sugar are addressed in GOOD vs BAD SWEETENERS.
  4. This picture is a summary of different methods of refining various types of grains. For that reason it cannot be completely accurate in all components and their proportions. Its main purpose is to illustrate the gradual progression from whole grain to ever smaller parts, and how – if the refining continues to its end – we get the same substances as we get through digestion: glucose and other simple sugars from carbohydrates, fatty acids and glycerol from fats, and amino acids from proteins.
  5. Rudolf Steiner, Dornach, 22.09.1923; www.rsarchive.org
  6. Karen Sullivan, Illustrated Elements of Vitamins & Minerals, HarperCollins Publishers, London, 2002
  7. Katharina Gustavs, Super Breakfast Cereals, Whole grains for good health and great taste, Alive Natural Health Guides, 2000. See also the chapter Question of Food Quality for a short overview of other losses caused by refining of wheat products.
  8. Source: Soil Association, Organic Farming, Food Quality and Human Health: A Review of the Evidence, 2001
  9. Gerhard Schmidt, The Essentials of Nutrition, Bio-dynamic Literature, USA, 1987
  10. The outcome of this Swiss research contradicts the recent scientific evidence that "phytates, found mainly in the husk of grain, are major inhibitors of iron absorption." (Source: Essentials of Human Nutrition, Oxford University Press, 2012). Even if this is true in some specific examples, it cannot be proclaimed as a general truth for all humanity, especially because there is no reference in scientific papers to the most important aspect of any food, its quality. Besides, it needs to be taken into account that "simply cooking the food will reduce the phytic acid to some degree. More effective methods are soaking in an acid medium, lactic acid fermentation, and sprouting." (Source: Wikipedia, December 2012).
  11. The transmission of genetic information (from parents to their offspring) which is the result of environmental factors, including the diet, is now a scientifically recognized fact that is investigated by epigenetics, the new branch of genetics.
  12. T.L. Cleave, The Saccharine Disease, available on www.journeytoforever.org
  13. This recommendation has been issued by the ‘Food and Nutrition Board of the Institute of Medicine’ from USA. The recommended amounts for other dietary minerals vary from 4700 mg to 2.4 µg. Source: Wikipedia/Dietary Reference Intake, September 2015
  14. In FOOD vs STIMULANTS there is an explanation as to why such food supplements are counted as medicines, and not as simple ways of providing the body with nutrients lacking in food.
  15. There are two very similar methods of adding minerals and vitamins to food: one is called 'enrichment' and refers to the addition of minerals or vitamins to replace those lost due to processing ; another is called 'fortification' and refers to the addition of minerals or vitamins to a particular food with the aim to 'improve' its nutritional value, irrespective of whether the nutrients were in the food before processing or not.
  16. Here we need to differentiate between natural food supplements, such as plant elixirs, or other natural plant products, and supplements in the form of pills and tablets. For further clarification see FOOD vs STIMULANTS.
  17. This is Gerhard Schmidt’s summary of the impacts of iron in his book The Essentials of Nutrition (see note 9) based on Steiner’s descriptions from various sources. Two short quotes in his text are from Steiner (Dornach, 24.10.1923 and Prague, 27.03.1911). 
  18. Rudolf Steiner, quoted in The Essentials of Nutrition (see note 9)
  19. See note 9
  20. See note 9
  21. According to Wikipedia "iron deficiency is the most prevalent deficiency state on a worldwide basis" and in Sullivan's book (see note 6) it is stated that more than 500 million people around the world suffer from anaemia.