Organic versus Conventional Food

Organic food has more vitality than conventionally produced food. Vitality is an expression of the life forces present in all living organisms. The source behind all schools of organic farming is the new science of life which - when properly implemented - enables organic growers to produce food of superior vitality. On the other side we have the conventional method which needs chemical ‘shields’ to protect the living organisms from forces of nature which want to destroy the weakest ones as a part of the process of natural selection.

Introductory Reading:

INORGANIC vs ORGANIC SUBSTANCES

Modern Agriculture: The Vicious Circle of Decreasing Life

Modern industrial agriculture is the offspring of scientific thinking and chemical engineering. The materialistic, reductionist, and mechanistic approach of modern science is very useful in the advancement of modern technology that is using the substances from the mineral kingdom, but it has its limits and serious drawbacks when applied in agriculture. [1] For here we are dealing with living organisms – microorganisms, plants and animals – and with natural food containing living forces.

For example, the use of artificial fertiliser increases the electric charge between the earth (negative pole) and the upper part of the plant (positive pole). This raises the electro-osmotic pressure and consequently plants suck up more water than usual. Thus artificial fertiliser does not increase plant growth by producing more cells – which is the normal way of growing – but it increases the cells because of the larger amount of water in them. [2] This can be noticed in the watery taste of conventionally grown fruit and vegetables. A further consequence of expanded cells are thinner cell walls which are more sensitive to environmental conditions and more vulnerable to outer impacts. This results in weaker, less vital plants.

Such artificially 'swollen' plants do not do very well in a natural environment where is necessary for the survival of each plant species that only the strongest and fittest can thrive. Plants grown in conventional fields need the help of synthetic herbicides, insecticides and other types of pesticides. These agrochemicals create a protective barrier against so-called 'weeds', 'harmful' insects and microorganisms, and other so-called 'parasites' which have the role in nature to remove and break down those plants which don't possess enough life forces to be capable to survive without such help.

Of course, with such an approach we create serious problems in the whole chain of food production. Such plants are fed to animals which need antibiotics to keep them 'healthy' and alive; in food processing they need food additives to make food 'palatable' and prevent its decay; and finally people who eat such food need medical drugs to keep them in 'good health'. But, the truth which many don't want to see is that these substances work as 'chemical shields' against the forces of natural selection which would otherwise destroy organisms which are too weak to survive in a natural environment.

There are two key sources behind the vicious circle of decreasing life in conventional food production:

In this light we can see the use of genetically modified organisms as the logical step in the development of such an approach. Genetic engineering tries to 'solve' problems which have been amassed by the same one-sided thinking, which treats the living organisms as types of 'food machines' – with the aim to produce food as cheaply and as quickly as possible. Because the problems in conventional food production cannot be effectively solved any more by the use of chemical engineering only, modern genetic science is offering help with its radical interventions into the basic structures of the living organisms. If those who promote genetic engineering prevail, the final result will be loss of suitable living forms for healthy life on earth.

Organic Agriculture: The Circle of Increasing Life

One of the most fundamental principles of organic farming and food processing is that only life stimulates life. This means that only soil which is teeming with life forces can produce strong plants, which in turn provide healthier food for animals and humans, which then contribute with their actions to the improvement of the quality of soil and other conditions that affect the food production. Here we have a circle of increasing vitality and health. For example, if we just look at the effect of earthworms – which have in organic farming a very important role – we notice that they help in the airing and fertilising of the soil. Their castings contain high amounts of nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium, as well as other minerals and micronutrients necessary for the healthy growth of plants.

The circle of life presents an ideal picture. The most important aspect is that we are aware that all we do at any stage of food production is dependent on a multitude of factors, so we can never claim that further improvement is not possible. However, it is crucial that we move in the right direction – that is, in the direction of ever increasing vitality and food quality.

There are two key sources behind the circle of increasing vitality in organic food production:

In this context "it is particularly important that we nourish the plants themselves in the right way. Here you must consider the fact that the plants are something living. The plants are not minerals; they are something living. A plant comes to us out of the seed we put in the ground. The plant cannot flourish unless the soil itself is to some degree alive. And how do we make the soil alive? By manuring it properly! Yes, proper manuring is what will give us really good plant proteins.

It's no use thinking that one can make fertilizer simply by combining substances that are present in cow manure. One must see clearly that cow manure does not come out of a chemist's laboratory but out of a laboratory that is far more scientific – it comes from the far, far more scientific laboratory inside the cow. And for this reason cow manure is the stuff that not only makes the roots of plants strong, but that works up powerfully into the fruits and produces good, proper protein in the plants which makes man vigorous." [4] always when he eats good natural food.

Now we can understand why in organic farming so much importance is given to the enlivening of the soil. Behind this approach is a more or less conscious awareness that although "plants themselves could never be diseased in a primary sense, since they are produce of a healthy living world, they can suffer from diseased conditions in their environment, especially in the soil; the causes of so-called plant diseases should be sought there," [5] in the environmental impacts. Thus we can also understand why everything we do in each step has an effect on the level of living forces in the soil, plants and animals, and why it will all inevitably affect the final quality of food.

Plants as the Source of Life on Earth

Plants grow out of the mineral realm and provide food for animals and human beings. Thus they form the living bridge between the dead minerals and living organisms. [6] In FOURFOLD HUMAN BEING plants are described as organisms consisting of two bodies only: physical and etheric body. The essence of the etheric body is life and for that reason we can comprehend why plants manifest various life functions to such an extreme degree as they do when we investigate them.

But plants do not work in isolation; they form interrelationships to everything around them, to the visible and invisible realms of existence. Plants live in the midst of four elements of earth, water, air, and warmth. They breathe and thus produce oxygen; they regulate microclimatic conditions, such as warmth, wind, and moisture in the surrounding earth and in the air. The mineral kingdom provides the basis from which the plants grow; besides this it provides chemical elements which plants absorb via intricate underground relationships and activities.

"Plant roots, though confined in space, have an extremely large surface area. This root surface releases differing amounts of chemicals at different locations, strongly regulating the local biocommunity throughout the life of the plant. These compounds promote the growth of bacteria and fungi, stimulate soil microflora respiration, stimulate the growth of nitrogen-fixing bacteria, and increase the numbers and mass of nitrogen nodules, their haemoglobin content, and more. But their actions are not random, nor is it random bacteria, fungi, and microflora that are affected. The newly germinating plant releases compounds that literally call the proper bacteria to the area where it is growing. Bacteria are so attuned to these chemicals that they respond to them even if they are present only in parts per billion. And these plant bacteria are species specific. The compounds that plants release into the soil are in such combinations and ratios that the health of their bacterial community is maxi­mized. The bacteria respond in kind. Some of the microorganisms, for example, provide metals from the soil, such as zinc, that the plant needs to grow. The better the bacterial population establishes itself and the more healthy and active it is, the healthier and better plants grow.

The newly photosynthesizing plant also releases compounds that initiate the growth of revolutionary fungi (mycelia) around its roots. The compounds chemically cue specific mycelial spores to germinate, potentiate their growth, and exert powerfully attractive forces on all (already growing) symbiotic mycelia in the vicinity, calling them to the newly emerging plant. As with bacterial cues, these compounds can be strongly active, even at dilutions of parts per billion. The mycelia, which are small hairlike filaments growing throughout the upper layers of the soil, attach themselves to the surface of the seedling's root (as do some bacteria), sometimes penetrating the root body, to form a complex symbiotic relationship called mycorrhiza. [7] This will last throughout the life of the plant. The plant, through photosynthesis, creates sugars and secondary compounds that the mycelia need for growth. The mycelia in turn provide substances the plant needs (nitrogen and phos­phate uptake, for instance, can increase 7,000 percent), produce complex polysaccharides that stimulate the plant's immune functioning, and facilitate chemical communication (through its mycelial network) between all the plants in its area" [8] which are connected to the same fungal network.

Plants are also surrounded by cosmic ethers – warmth ether, light ether, chemical ether, and life ether. Warmth ether is the supersensible aspect of physical warmth which is essential for developing flowers, fruits and seeds. Light ether is the essential factor in the photosynthesis which enables synthesis of carbohydrates, fats, and proteins out of mineral elements. Chemical ether is manifested in the enormous capacity of plants to produce all kinds of chemical substances found in them. [9] And where in the plants can we see the working of life ether? In the simple fact that without plants no higher form of life on earth would exist.

Plants do not form symbiotic relationships only with fungi and bacteria underground, but also with other forms of life: with insects and birds as pollinators; with animals which spread their seeds, etc. But plants do not stop with such relationships found by natural science, they are also under more invisible influences coming from the cosmic bodies and stars. The awareness and purposeful use of this knowledge in the growth of plants is one of the main differences which distinguish biodynamic agriculture from an organic one. [10]

For example, "there are two things we need to observe about the life of plants. The first is the fact that plants possess the power of reproduction. Not only the plant world in general but also each individual species develops the ability to bring forth its own kind. That is the one side. The other side is the fact that plants, as members of a comparatively lower kingdom of nature, serve as nourishment for members of the higher kingdoms. In everything related to the inner force of reproduction and growth, in everything that makes one generation of plants follow another, Moon, Venus, and Mercury are working from the cosmos into the Earth by way of lime and similar substances. If we look only at plants that we do not eat, plants that simply renew themselves over and over again, it's as if we were only interested in the influence of the cosmos as it manifests in the forces of Venus, Mercury, and Moon, since these are the forces involved in plant reproduction on Earth. On the other hand, when plants become food or fodder, when they develop in such a way as to form substances that can nourish people or animals, then Mars, Jupiter, and Saturn are involved, via substances like silica. These substances make the plant receptive to the expanses of the universe; they arouse the plant's senses so that it takes up from the whole surrounding universe what is shaped by the distant planets, by Mars, Jupiter, and Saturn. Conversely, what makes a plant capable of reproduction is taken up from the spheres of Moon, Venus, and Mercury." [11] Or in other words, heavenly bodies between the Earth and the Sun are conveying to the plants those forces which enable their growth and reproduction, while planets between the Earth and the outer expanses of the universe are conveying to the plants those forces which enable their ripening and production of fruits.

The above description of the planetary influences serves only as an illustration which shows that for the proper life of plants they are necessary not only for the connections of plants with their mineral surroundings and with the beings from the other kingdoms of nature, but also the more hidden interplay with the invisible cosmic forces. [12] If we really want to understand the plants we need to know that "a plant such as we see in the external world is a being which is made up of a physical and etheric body. At the same time it is a being which brings to our notice the fact that what we call the physical and etheric body are in principle healthy, and that it has to wait until it meets with an external injury before it can become diseased. In the case of a diseased plant we are never able to say that the original etheric body itself is changed, but only that all kinds of disturbances and harmful influences from outside have penetrated into the physical body and especially into the etheric body" [13] of a plant.

Now we can look at one example of such harmful influence coming from outside which needs to be brought to the core of our attention when we investigate the difference in the quality of organic and conventional farming methods.

Harmful Effects of Artificial Fertiliser on Growth of Plant

From the above description it is evident that the life of plants is dominated by relationships with their environment and by symbiotic collaborations with other forms of life. Even the antagonistic activities between various species contribute to the final outcome – the harmonious ecosystem which is capable of regulating itself. In the organic cultivation of plants we strive to emulate and use these natural self-regulatory processes and thus maintain the health of plants. In contrast to this, the use of artificial fertiliser has very negative effects on the life and health of plants.

As we have seen, plants are not just passive receptors of influences coming from outside but they are very active in providing themselves with the minerals and other elements they need for proper growth. In fact, plants are choosing what they will absorb from their environment. But a "plant that is feed by artificial fertiliser is no longer capable of getting its food from the soil with the choice of suitable nutrients. Fertiliser dissolves in water and the plant receives the nutrients contained in fertilisers by the absorption of water through the roots. These nutrients which have not been chosen by plant itself according to its needs in cooperation with specific bacteria are not suitable for the plant's proper nourishment." [14] This effect – in combination with the accelerated absorption of water due to increase in electro-osmotic pressure – we can see as the forced feeding of plants based on human arbitrary decision about what is good for plants and what is not. This approach results in the weakening of the plants’ vitality and in the loss of food quality.

The use of artificial fertiliser has another negative effect: it suppresses the life of microorganisms and mycorrhizal association. This is evident from the cases of long-term use of artificial fertiliser which has lead – in cooperation with the use of herbicides and pesticides – to the complete loss of other life-forms in the soil. What is left is more or less sand and dust. Such environment prevents plants from obtaining all the minerals they need for healthy growth. This is the paradox of the use of artificial mineral fertiliser: it 'cuts' the plants from living symbiotic relationships with other life-forms in the soil and thus prevents them from obtaining all the mineral substances they need. Such development also hinders the inflow of beneficial cosmic forces. The final results are plants isolated from living interrelationships with the natural environment and surrounding universe. Such plants cannot nourish human beings in the same manner as those grown as nature intended. [15]

On top of this we need to be aware that since the beginning of modern agriculture substances which have never before been used in food production are entering into our food chain. These are hydrocarbons, the dead geological remnants of former living organisms. The main characteristic of these substances – to which belong petroleum, coal, and natural gas – is that they no longer contain oxygen, the carrier of cosmic life. [16] In spiritual science the realm from which we get these hydrocarbons is called 'subnature'. While these substances are very useful and effective sources of energy in industry and transport, they do not have any beneficial effects on the quality of our food. We could even say that their primary effect is to create an opposition to the life forces in the living organisms. For that reason we should not use them as a means for growing plants, if we want to support and evolve the intrinsic life forces of the plants and subsequently of all higher forms of life.

For a complementary perspective see:

FOOD AS SOURCE OF ENERGY

DIETARY CONCLUSIONS & PRACTICAL INSTRUCTIONS

By eating organic foods we avoid artificial chemical substances used in conventionally produced food (e.g. pesticides and food additives), including some other nasty things (e.g. food additives made from human hair [17] or insects). This alone is worth the extra money usually paid for organic food, but we must be aware that there are various grades of quality inside organically produced food itself.

Within each of these groups there are no two foods of the same quality. Good quality is dependent on many factors – such as microclimate, the quality of soil, the quality of seeds [20] – and methods and materials which are used or not used by farmers and gardeners. Unfortunately it needs to be admitted that basic standards for organic agriculture and food processing (i.e. The IFOAM Organic Standards) are not yet as they should be if the production of the best quality food were the top priority. For example, these standards are allowing the use of modern plant hybrids in spite of the fact that they were developed with the main aim to produce the highest quantities of uniformly shaped plant products. The members of the organic movement who are using these seeds are somehow forgetful that the vitality and health of plants is essentially dependent on the vitality and health of seeds!

This example shows that the most important impact on the final quality of food is made by the knowledge and skills of people involved in food production. For good quality we need more masters in the area of farming and food processing and time to learn new skills. And time to heal all barren land so that it can be fertile again, giving us crops full of life and vital forces.

See HOLISTIC FOOD ‘PYRAMID’ for practical quality guidelines.

WARNING: You always have to put the above practical dietary instructions inside the framework of GENERAL NUTRITIONAL GUIDELINES with the aim to know their limits when looking for a solution of a specific nutritional problem. You also need to be familiar with THE ROLE OF NUTRITIONAL GUIDELINES with the aim to avoid any one-sided conclusions.

NOTES

  1. These three aspects of modern science are exquisitely characterised by Fritjof Capra in the book The Turning Point (Flamingo, 1983).
  2. This is a summary of three basic factors which influence the soil and circulation of plant sap when we use artificial fertilizer. They are described in full in the Croatian book Organic Food Production by Pavao Krišković (see note 14). It is the only book known to me which describes the principle of electro-osmosis as the mechanism which enable movement of water (plant sap) from the roots to the branches of trees against the forces of gravity.
  3. The great majority of these agrochemicals can be made entirely or partially from hydrocarbons. Even in the group of food additives one can find synthetic dyes, preservatives, and sweeteners (saccharine) made from these substances.
  4. Rudolf Steiner, Dornach, 2.08.1924; combined quote from two translations (one from www.rsarchive.org)
  5. Ehrenfried E. Pfeiffer, M.D., Appendix C from Agriculture by Rudolf Steiner (see note 11). In the quote the author recapitulate the explanation given to him in private conversation with Steiner.
  6. In spiritual science the mineral kingdom is regarded as dead/lifeless only from a physical perspective in comparison with the plant and animal kingdom. When looked at from a spiritual perspective then we see the physical elements as mediators of diverse spiritual forces which are indispensible for the existence of living organisms. This is evident if we just look at the spiritual forces behind the four main elements of organic world: hydrogen, oxygen, hydrogen and carbon (see COSMIC ORIGIN OF LIVING SUBSTANCES).
  7. It is estimated that 95% of all green plants depend on at least one mycorrhizal association and that about 80% of all plant species in the world create mycorrhizal symbiosis with fungi. Plants without any fungal relationship include all the species of brassicas: cabbage, cauliflower, Brussels sprouts, kale, broccoli, etc. (Source: Robert Kourik, Roots Demystified, Metamorphic Press, 2008)
  8. Stephen Harrod Buhner, The Lost Language of Plants, Chelsea Green Publishing, Vermont, 2002
  9. The latest findings of chemical compositions of plants present an immense diversity of chemical compounds found in a single plant (see The Chemistry Found in a Single Yarrow Plant). From this we could even say that the science of chemistry is nothing else but an imitation of the living chemistry of the plant kingdom.
  10. This difference does not mean that plants in organic farming are not subjected to cosmic influences, but only that organic farmers are more focused on the promotion of healthy relationships of plants with other life-forms, while they are not aware of the great significance of the more hidden cosmic influences or they do not use methods which stimulate these cosmic influences. Of course, there are exceptions among organic farmers, but such farmers for that very reason sooner or later convert to the biodynamic method of cultivation.
  11. Rudolf Steiner, Agriculture, Bio-Dynamic Farming and Gardening Association, USA, 1993
  12. The proper understanding of cosmic influences on the life of plants demands serious study. If you are keen to explore this topic then you can start with Steiner's lectures from his agricultural course (see note 11) which form the basis of biodynamic farming.
  13. Rudolf Steiner, Hamburg, 18.05.1910; www.rsarchive.org
  14. Pavao Krišković, Biološko pridelovanje hrane (Organic Food Production), Slovenian translation: Kmečki glas, Ljubljana, 1993
  15. In this context we can understand the tendency of conventional agriculture to create controlled environments for the growth of plants in glasshouses and factories. The idea of this approach is to prevent access to those natural influences which are hindering the cultivation of modern plants in a natural environment.
  16. For the description of oxygen as carrier of cosmic life see COSMIC ORIGIN OF LIVING SUBSTANCES.
  17. Human hair is collected from barber shops, cleaned and chopped. "This sort of hair is sold on to chemical companies which convert it into amino acids for use in food, medicines and many other products." Source: article in The Independent Magazine, 2001
  18. One of the main reasons why is Demeter food better than organic is that biodynamic farmers use special preparations for increasing the soil and plant vitality which are not used in other methods of organic farming.
  19. Some producers offer food products labelled ‘Natural’. But this word can mean many things, depending on the producer. It is usually used for products such as legumes, nuts, dry fruits, which haven’t been subjected to any further food processing and don't contain any additives. Of course, such products are more natural than other conventional food, but there is no guarantee that they have been grown organically. The label ‘Natural’ in principle cannot be trusted, the only exception being when we actually know the producer and his methods of food production.
  20. About great importance of open pollinated seeds for vitality of crops see Open Pollinated Seeds Website.